Apparently, LeAnn was unable to commit to such a bold and unequivocal lie, made obtuse statements instead. She said things like, “Not everything in our lives is always black and white.” Hoping it would blow over, she inadvertently stoked the rumor mill.
She said it was a “difficult time” but neither refuted nor denied the claims of the scandalous “US Weekly” write-up. In the end, her feeble response revealed a tiny crack in Eddie’s “just friends” story. It was hastily exploited by the press, erupting into a violent, all-out media storm.
Rumors Hit the Headlines
By March 2009, stories about LeAnn and Eddie’s behind-the-scenes love affair begin to make the rounds. At first, they denied it. But no matter how much the couple refuted the allegations, the sensational news about the double extra-marital affair was gaining traction.
LeAnn and Eddie had been witnessed sharing intimate conversations and ducking away in secret. The two realized that they must confront the allegations.
Deny, Deny, Deny
The day the story broke, Eddie Cibrian found himself with his back up against the wall. "US Weekly" released the story about the secret "Northern Lights" affair, and it demanded a response. Eddie told the press he had only gone out to dinner with LeAnn because they were friends.
Flabbergasted, he added, “The ridiculous thing is that people believe I would do something like this, period. Much less do it in a public place. The false accusations are obviously causing a rift at home, but I and my family will get through this together.”
In Eddie’s household, things were getting a little crazy. He said he had done no wrong and their marriage was fine, but his wife Brandi was not on the same page. Brandi was furious.
When "US Weekly" reported the cheating scandal, she knew it was true and long expected that Eddie had been disloyal. Disgusted, she told the magazine, “Eddie and LeAnn deserve each other.” The truth was Brandi and Eddie had already separated, agreeing with the best intentions to co-parent their sons, and they announced the decision in a statement.
LeAnn Moves Out
Once Brandi and Eddie’s separation was announced, news leaked out about LeAnn’s marriage. LeAnn and Dean were supposedly going to work on their relationship, but a source told "People" magazine that they had moved out of their shared home.
Meanwhile, doubling down on his lie, Eddie insisted to the press that the affair is “a fabricated story that is using random snapshots as connective tissue to create a scandalous relationship.” Next? Hours later, an intimate video of Eddie and LeAnn together was leaked to the press. They were officially caught red-handed.